A joint plan by the UK and Welsh governments has been devised to reduce NHS waiting lists by allowing patients from Wales to receive treatment in England, and vice-versa. Welsh NHS dentistry will also be used as a model for improving services in England, despite concerns from the British Dental Association.
In a step towards cross-border collaboration, the UK and Welsh governments are to partner for the first time in addressing the NHS waiting lists crisis. With waiting lists at record highs on both sides of the border, ministers from Westminster and the Senedd are keen to exchange best practices to alleviate pressure on healthcare services in both England and Wales.
The collaboration aims to enhance healthcare delivery, reduce patient waiting times, and strengthen ties between the two Labour-led governments, particularly on key issues like surgical procedures and dental care.
UK and Welsh Collaboration
The UK and Welsh governments have long managed their respective NHS services independently, with healthcare being a devolved responsibility in Wales. However, growing concerns over lengthy waiting times and gaps in service provision have prompted Labour leaders to consider a cooperative approach. Welsh Secretary Jo Stevens and First Minister Eluned Morgan are spearheading efforts to pool resources and expertise, particularly in areas like surgical procedures and dental care, where mutual aid partnerships could reduce backlogs.
Stevens emphasised that the new partnership would focus on practical solutions rather than political point-scoring. “We are acting quickly to tackle one of the biggest shared challenges our two governments face,” she said, referring to the strain on NHS resources. For patients, this initiative could mean receiving treatment in either England or Wales, depending on where capacity allows for faster care.
Learning from Each Other: Dentistry as a Model
Dentistry has emerged as a focal point for collaboration. The Welsh Government’s recent success in unlocking 400,000 additional dental appointments over the past two years has caught the attention of policymakers in England. As part of this new cross-border plan, the UK Government aims to replicate this success with a target of delivering 700,000 new dental appointments in England.
At the same time, Wales stands to benefit from England’s experience in optimising NHS operations, with new working models expected to generate 40,000 extra appointments per week. This exchange could provide a much-needed boost to both nations’ healthcare services, which have been under severe strain in recent years.
This collaboration on dental care comes despite previous warnings from the British Dental Association (BDA) about the risk of NHS dentistry disappearing in Wales. The BDA has criticised recent changes to contracts that prioritised new patients at the expense of existing ones. However, both governments aim to improve dental care access, and the Welsh Government’s success in creating 400,000 new appointments will serve as a model for NHS England.
Political Reactions
Despite the optimism surrounding the partnership, the initiative has faced criticism. Welsh Conservative shadow health minister Sam Rowlands described the move as “long overdue” and accused the Labour Welsh Government of previously rejecting similar offers from the Conservative UK government. “This collaboration could have come sooner,” he argued, “but it is welcome news if it delivers for patients.”
Plaid Cymru’s health spokesperson, Mabon ap Gwynfor, has expressed scepticism, calling for deeper reforms. He warned that while collaboration is a positive step, it might fall short of addressing the systemic issues plaguing the Welsh NHS, including staff shortages, underfunding, and structural inefficiencies. “Cosmetic collaboration with Westminster will not solve the deep-rooted problems in Wales’s NHS,” he cautioned.
Challenges Ahead
Both the UK and Welsh NHS systems face significant hurdles. In Wales, 615,300 patients are currently on waiting lists, with over 23,000 waiting more than two years for treatment. In England, similar pressures are exacerbated by staffing shortages, outdated infrastructure, and increasing demand. Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer has acknowledged the need for reform, stating that the NHS in Wales “desperately” needs change.
While cross-border collaboration may ease some of these pressures, there are concerns about its long-term efficacy. As Plaid Cymru pointed out, without significant investments in recruitment, retention, and modernisation, the collaboration risks being a short-term fix rather than a sustainable solution.
Final Thought
The joint initiative between the UK and Welsh governments represents a common-sense approach to tackling the healthcare crisis. The exchange of best practices, particularly around dental care and surgical procedures, could provide much-needed relief to overstretched NHS services. However, for this collaboration to truly succeed, it must be accompanied by deeper, systemic reforms.
A clear framework for how cross-border cooperation will be implemented is essential. The NHS in both nations faces complex challenges that cannot be resolved through partnerships alone. Issues like staff retention, resource allocation, and long-term investment need to be addressed. While collaboration offers an opportunity for immediate improvements, it should be viewed as part of a broader strategy to modernise and future-proof the NHS.
In conclusion, this partnership marks a positive shift in the relationship between the two governments, but it will only be successful if it leads to more ambitious and far-reaching reforms. MPs, ministers, and council leaders must ensure that this is the first step in a more comprehensive overhaul of healthcare in the UK.
To become a one of Curia’s Health, Care and Life Sciences Research Group Subscribers, please email team@curiauk.com. For more of Curia’s analysis of UK healthcare policy, please click here.