Since 2007, smoking has been prohibited in enclosed public areas and workplaces in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland. Scotland has also implemented this ban since 2006. Public health has significantly improved as a result, especially for young people. Thus, the question arises as to whether the proposed outdoor smoking clamp down will have far reaching positive consequences.
An Outline of the Proposed Government Legislation
In an effort to lessen the number of avoidable fatalities associated with tobacco use and the strain on the NHS, Prime Minister Keir Starmer said his government is considering stricter regulations regarding outdoor smoking. However, the extent of the UK government’s considerations is not yet known to us.
This could mean banning smoking in places such as pub gardens, outdoor restaurants, outside hospitals and sports grounds.
The Tobacco and Vapes Bill, which was presented by the previous Conservative administration, forbids the sale of cigarettes or any other tobacco product to anybody born on or after January 1, 2009.
The bill was not approved by parliament prior to the UK election. However, the recently elected Labour government has pledged to bring the legislation back and may expand the prohibitions on smoking, including banning it from public spaces like bars and hospitals. A new ban would only be applicable in England. Devolved administrations may decide to implement comparable laws.
A Comparative Approach: Uruguay and Australia
The UK is not the first country to contemplate this kind of legislation.
In 2006, Uruguay became the first country in South America to become completely smoke-free by enacting a ban on smoking in all public spaces and workplaces, said the WHO. As a result, cigarette consumption and adult smoking prevalence have dropped drastically. From 2005, (the year the smoke-free law was passed) to 2011, per capita cigarette consumption in Uruguay has dropped an average of 4.3 percent per year, while prevalence fell by an average of 3.3 percent per year. The campaign was said to improve the health of the population – illustrated by the number of non-hospital emergency visits for bronchospasm decreasing by 15%.
Australia has seen significant success in reducing smoking rates through a mix of policies, including outdoor smoking bans in various public spaces such as parks, playgrounds, and pub gardens. These bans, implemented gradually over the past two decades, have helped lower the daily smoking rate to 8.3%, down from 24% in 1991. The bans have also reshaped pub culture, with smoking relegated to designated areas, allowing more families to enjoy smoke-free environments. This shift has contributed to a decline in smoking-related illnesses and fostered a broader acceptance of smoke-free public spaces.
Fiscal Implications
The introduction of outdoor smoking bans carries a range of economic impacts, presenting both opportunities and challenges.
On the positive side, these bans can lead to long-term financial benefits for the hospitality sector. By creating smoke-free environments, pubs and restaurants may attract a broader clientele, including families and non-smokers, thereby increasing overall revenue.
Additionally, reduced smoking rates contribute to lower healthcare costs by decreasing the prevalence of smoking-related illnesses, which can alleviate the financial strain on public health systems like the NHS. Environmental benefits, such as less cigarette litter, also translate to cost savings for businesses and local governments responsible for maintenance and cleanup.
Conversely, small businesses, particularly those heavily reliant on smoking patrons, might experience a decline in revenue as some customers seek alternative venues where they can smoke. This shift can lead to short-term financial strain and, in some cases, business closures. Moreover, the tobacco industry itself could face reduced sales, impacting jobs and tax revenues associated with tobacco products.
Final Thought
The progression of smoking bans from indoor to outdoor spaces marks a significant shift in public health policy, reflecting the growing recognition of the harms of tobacco not only to smokers but also to the broader community. The proposed outdoor smoking clampdown by the UK government, if implemented, could build on the successes seen in countries like Uruguay and Australia, where comprehensive smoking bans have led to improvements in public health and reduced smoking rates.
However, the potential economic ramifications for small businesses and the tobacco industry cannot be overlooked. While there are long-term benefits, including reduced healthcare costs and a cleaner environment, the short-term challenges for certain sectors might be significant.
To find out more about our NHS Innovation and Life Sciences Research Group, please click here, and sign up to our newsletter to receive additional insight and updates.