The current state of the effectiveness and fairness of the criminal justice system, encompassing accountability for offenders, justice for victims, and efforts to prevent recidivism has been heavily scrutinised by shadow Labour ministers.
There is a need to address systemic failures highlighted by recent revelations, such as the significant number of unfulfilled punishments. Key policy considerations include reforming sentencing practices, enhancing rehabilitation programmes, and promoting community-driven approaches to crime prevention. At its core, the policy issue seeks to ensure that the justice system serves its intended purpose of safeguarding communities, upholding rights, and fostering meaningful rehabilitation for all individuals involved.
Unfulfilled punishment: A lapse in justice
Official Ministry of Justice figures expose a disconcerting reality: nearly 280,000 hours of punishment were written off within the past year alone. Shockingly, thousands of individuals, ordered to undertake unpaid work such as graffiti cleaning as part of their sentence, have managed to evade completion of their assigned tasks, as revealed by new data.
These punishments, typically prescribed for offenses meriting less than two years of imprisonment, come with a stipulation: they cannot be extended beyond a duration determined by a judge. Consequently, once this timeframe elapses, any remaining work is no longer obligatory.
Labour has criticised the government, contending that such revelations signify a blatant abandonment of victims. Shadow Justice Secretary Shabna Mahmood has articulated the public sentiment stating, “The public have no faith that justice will be done.” Victims, she emphasises, anticipate the completion of sentences and the execution of community payback work.
In response to these alarming findings, Labour has made a pledge: to ensure that criminals complete their sentences, complete their restitution, and undergo comprehensive rehabilitation and reintegration measures.
Insights from Curia’s Levelling Up Inquiry
At the end of 2023, the Levelling Up Commission held an online panel on crime, justice, and rehabilitation.
Part one focused on prevention and community building while part two looked at rehabilitating offenders and reducing recidivism.
Chaired by Paula Sherriff, former MP and Shadow Secretary for Mental and Social Care, the panel included:
- Tom McNeil – Assistant Police and Crime Commissioner in the West Midlands
- Riana Taylor – CEO of Circles UK
- Dr Theo Gavrielides – CEO of Restorative Justice For All
- Dr Jo Easton – Director of Policy and Advocacy at Unlock
Crime Prevention and Community Building:
Tom McNeil emphasised the need for a shift in how police forces are evaluated, advocating for a mandated emphasis on community rehabilitation to measure their effectiveness.
Riana Taylor underscored the failure of short-term crime prevention strategies, urging for long-term initiatives lasting 20-25 years to address root causes effectively. She stated that “people who commit offences have a long history of adverse childhood experiences – many of them come from significant trauma. There is no quick fix, and these short-term programmes never really go anywhere. You’re not going to sort the problem out that way.”
Dr Theo Gavrielides advocated for restorative justice as a holistic approach to tackle community tensions and combat power abuse, stressing the importance of empowering communities. – “you can’t truly empower citizens and achieve levelling up if you don’t address the power abuse, we currently experience. We talk about what we need to change within institutions in terms of barriers and cultures, but what we haven’t tried to do is to truly empower communities instead.”
Rehabilitation and Reducing Recidivism:
Dr Jo Easton highlighted the significant barriers posed by criminal records, hindering rehabilitation efforts, and perpetuating lifelong impacts on individuals even after completing their sentences. “It’s all well and good providing people with rehabilitation support to get them job interviews but if employers have really strong policies around criminal records, then these people can be rejected straight away without even being seen.”
Riana Taylor expressed dismay over the scarcity and effectiveness of perpetrator rehabilitation programs in the UK, stressing the urgent need for their expansion and evaluation to prevent re-offending and support individuals in overcoming abusive behaviours.
Final thoughts:
There is an urgency for comprehensive reform in the criminal justice system. Labour’s critique and pledge highlight the imperative to uphold victim justice and ensure offenders complete their sentences.
The Levelling Up Commission’s recommendations, including a shift towards community rehabilitation and holistic approaches like restorative justice, offer a roadmap for addressing systemic failures and promoting meaningful rehabilitation. Bridging this gap demands concerted efforts to reform sentencing practices, enhance rehabilitation programs, and empower communities to foster a more just and equitable society.
To read the full article on Curia’s Levelling Up Commission: ‘Crime, Justice, and Rehabilitation Inquiry,’ please click here to subscribe to our newsletter and receive a copy of our latest edition of our journal coming out soon.