In the wake of Birmingham City Council’s financial collapse, a detailed investigation conducted by the Audit Reform Lab, based at the University of Sheffield, has revealed a catalogue of problems and errors that contributed to the crisis.
The report, led by Dr James Brackley, exposes significant misdiagnoses of the Council’s financial problems, ambiguity over key financial liabilities, and the detrimental impact of government-imposed financial measures. These findings have prompted calls for an independent inquiry and a comprehensive restructuring of the Council’s financial recovery plan.
The Financial Collapse: A Catalogue of Problems and Errors
The report identifies a series of missteps and systemic failures that led to Birmingham City Council issuing a section 114 ‘bankruptcy’ notice in September 2023. Among the most critical issues was the misdiagnosis of the Council’s financial troubles, which were initially attributed to a speculative £760 million equal pay liability. This figure, however, was never audited or confirmed by the external auditors, Grant Thornton, despite being used as a justification for the financial interventions that followed.
Adding to the Council’s woes was the disastrous implementation of a new Oracle IT system. Launched in April 2022, the system was intended to streamline various financial and administrative functions but instead resulted in tens of thousands of untraceable cash transactions. This failure not only inflated the Council’s deficits but also hampered its ability to monitor and manage its finances effectively.
The report criticises the central government’s response to these financial difficulties, particularly the decision by the former Levelling Up Secretary, Michael Gove, to initiate severe cuts and asset sales based on the misdiagnosed financial situation. These measures, the report argues, have jeopardised the Council’s ability to meet its statutory duties and have worsened financial outcomes for the city.
The Role of External Auditors and the Need for Accountability
One of the most concerning revelations in the report is the role played by Grant Thornton, the Council’s external auditors. Despite taking over £1 million in audit fees, Grant Thornton failed to provide clear confirmation of the equal pay liability that was central to the financial collapse narrative. This lack of clarity and transparency raises serious questions about the quality of external audits and the accountability of those involved.
Dr Brackley and his team have called for a full and independent inquiry into the events leading up to the Council’s financial collapse. They argue that the inquiry should examine not only the actions of Birmingham City Council but also the roles played by Oracle, Grant Thornton, and the former Conservative government.
Recommendations for a Revised Recovery Plan
In light of the findings, the Audit Reform Lab has proposed several key recommendations to guide Birmingham City Council back to financial stability. Chief among these is the restructuring of the Council’s financial support package to focus on the costs associated with the Oracle IT disaster rather than the speculative equal pay liability. This shift in focus, the report suggests, would allow the Council to balance its books over a longer period and avoid the need for drastic cuts to essential services.
The report also calls for the immediate suspension of asset sales unless they demonstrably contribute to the Council’s financial recovery. Instead, the focus should be on maintaining and enhancing revenue-generating assets to ensure long-term financial sustainability.
Final Thought
The financial collapse of Birmingham City Council serves as a stark reminder of the consequences of poor financial management and the need for robust accountability mechanisms in local government. The Audit Reform Lab’s report highlights the urgent need for an independent inquiry and a revised recovery plan that prioritises long-term stability over short-term fixes.
As the city struggles with the fallout of these events, it is crucial that lessons are learned, and measures are put in place to prevent such a crisis from occurring again.
The coming months will be critical as Birmingham City Council, with the support of the new UK government, seeks to implement these recommendations and restore confidence in its financial management. The eyes of local governments across the country will undoubtedly be watching closely, recognising that Birmingham’s experience could hold valuable lessons for the rest.
At Chamber UK, we seek to connect the council to the commons, so please send your any relevant press releases or analysis to info@chamberuk.com.